jobs.ac.uk - Great jobs for bright people
  • Find a Job
  • Find PhDs
  • Career Advice
  • Jobs by Email
  • Advertise a Job
  • Recruiters
  • Your Account

  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

career-advice.jobs.ac.uk

Secondary Sidebar

jobs.ac.uk Career Advice

  • CV and Cover Letter Advice
    • CV Tips
    • Free CV Templates
    • Cover Letters with Examples
    • Personal Profiles
    • CV Resources
  • Jobseeking and Interview Tips
    • Jobseeking Tips
    • Academic Interviews
    • Professional Interviews
    • Jobseeking and Interview Resources
  • Career Development
    • Academic Careers
    • Research Careers
    • Career Progression Stories
    • Professional Careers
    • Working in Industry
    • Career Development Resources
    • Global Careers
    • Working From Home
  • Women in Higher Education
  • FE Career Advice
    • FE CV & Interview Tips
    • Working in FE
    • Managing your Career in FE
    • FE Jobs Profiles
  • Resources
    • Academic Case Studies
    • Professional Case Studies
    • Job Profiles
      • Biological Science Jobs
      • Health and Medical Jobs
      • Engineering and Technology Jobs
      • Computer Science Jobs
      • Physical and Environmental Science Jobs
      • Professional Service Jobs
        • Business Development Manager Jobs Profile
        • Chef Jobs Profile
        • Civil Service Jobs Profile
        • Email Marketing Jobs Profile
        • SEO Jobs Profile
        • Office Admin Jobs
    • Vlogs
  • Webinars
  • Country Profiles
    • Africa
      • Egypt
      • Ghana
      • Kenya
      • Nigeria
      • South Africa
    • Americas
      • Canada
      • United States of America
    • Asia
      • Bahrain
      • Brunei
      • China
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Japan
      • Kazakhstan
      • Malaysia
      • Qatar
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Dubai
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • Turkey
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Work in Vietnam – Country Profile
      • Work in Uzbekistan – Country Profile
    • Europe
      • Belgium
      • Denmark
      • Finland
      • France
      • Germany
      • Ireland
      • Italy
      • Netherlands
      • Norway
      • Russia
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • United Kingdom
    • Oceania
      • Australia
      • New Zealand
  • PhD and Studentship Advice
    • PhD
    • Studentship Resources
    • Vlogs
  • Need help advertising a job?
  • About jobs.ac.uk
  • Ask A Professional
  • Academic Spotlight Interviews
  • Menu
    • CV and Cover Letter Advice
      • CV Tips
      • Free CV Templates
      • Cover Letters with Examples
      • Personal Profiles
      • CV Resources
    • Jobseeking and Interview Tips
      • Jobseeking Tips
      • Academic Interviews
      • Professional Interviews
      • Jobseeking and Interview Resources
    • Career Development
      • Academic Careers
      • Career Progression Stories
      • Research Careers
      • Professional Careers
      • Working in Industry
      • Career Development Resources
      • Global Careers
      • Working From Home
    • Women in Higher Education
    • FE Career Advice
      • FE CV & Interview Tips
      • Working in FE
      • Managing your Career in FE
      • FE Jobs Profiles
    • Resources
      • Academic Case Studies
      • Professional Case Studies
      • Interview questions tool
      • Vlogs
      • Job Profiles
        • Biological Science Jobs
        • Health and Medical Jobs
        • Engineering and Technology Jobs
        • Computer Science Jobs
        • Physical and Environmental Science Jobs
        • Professional Service Jobs
        • Civil Service jobs
    • Webinars
    • Country Profiles
      • Africa
        • Work in Egypt – Country Profile
        • Work in Ghana – Country Profile
        • Work in Kenya – Country Profile
        • Work in Nigeria – Country Profile
        • Work in South Africa – Country Profile
      • Americas
        • Work in Canada – Country Profile
        • Work in the United States of America – Country Profile
      • Asia
        • Work in Bahrain – Country Profile
        • Work in Brunei – Country Profile
        • Work in China – Country Profile
        • Work in Hong Kong – Country Profile
        • Work in India – Country Profile
        • Work in Japan – Country Profile
        • Work in Kazakhstan – Country Profile
        • Work in Malaysia – Country Profile
        • Work in Qatar – Country Profile
        • Work in Saudi Arabia – Country Profile
        • Work in Singapore – Country Profile
        • Work in South Korea – Country Profile
        • Work in Turkey – Country Profile
        • Work in United Arab Emirates – Country Profile
      • Dubai
      • Europe
        • Belgium Country Profile
        • Work in Denmark – Country Profile
        • Work in Finland – Country Profile
        • France Country Profile
        • Work in Germany – Country Profile
        • Work in Ireland – Country Profile
        • Work in Italy – Country Profile
        • Work in the Netherlands – Country Profile
        • Work in Norway – Country Profile
        • Work in Russia – Country Profile
        • Work in Spain – Country Profile
        • Work in Sweden – Country Profile
        • Work in Switzerland – Country Profile
        • Work in the United Kingdom – Country Profile
      • Oceania
        • Work in Australia – Country profile
        • Work in New Zealand – Country Profile
    • Studentship Advice
      • PhD
      • Studentship Resources
      • Vlogs
    • Need help advertising a job?
    • About jobs.ac.uk

Can peer-reviewing papers strengthen my CV?

woman working on article on laptop

No, but you should do it anyway.

There’s an awful lot of impassioned discourse out there around our peer-review system – much of it related to the fact that publishers usually don’t pay reviewers. While for many academics reviewing is part of the service component of a job, for others (like most graduate students and postdocs) it’s a volunteer activity. So why do it?

The invention of services that track and certify your reviewing history, like Publons, suggests that having reviewed papers might carry some weight on your CV as you build a portfolio of scholarly contributions. Well, reviewing (when done well) is a scholarly contribution; but I don’t think you should count on it to strengthen your CV. I’ve been part of a lot of CV assessments over the years – for grant panels, hiring committees, tenure assessments, you name it. I’ve never seen someone’s peer-review record receive any serious discussion; and in a hiring context, I’ve never seen it come up at all. Service defined more broadly does, but in my experience peer-review just isn’t seen as the kind of service that can lead to one candidate being preferred over another.

If volunteering to peer-review doesn’t strengthen your CV, should you give it a pass? After all, there are plenty of things you can do with your time that do strengthen a CV. Passing on peer-review would be a mistake, though. There are benefits to peer-reviewing; they just aren’t (directly) to do with your CV. I’ll suggest four ways that reviewing can help you build a scholarly career.

First, reviewing gives you an early look at some of the very freshest work in your field

You’ll read and think carefully about new hypotheses, new methods, new data, and new interpretations – and this can only strengthen your own approach to your work. Yes, preprinting in some disciplines has reduced this advantage, as many manuscripts are public before they enter the peer-review system; but until preprinting becomes universal there will be value in early exposure to your colleagues’ most recent progress.

Second, reviewing is a chance to engage deeply and critically (but constructively!) with writing

You’ll think carefully about the way the authors presented their work: their choice of content, their organization, their writing style, their designs for figures and tables. You’ll find good choices you can emulate, and mistakes you can avoid, in your own academic writing. It’s true that you can think carefully and thoroughly about anything you read; but you’re most likely to engage this way with some writing when you’re doing it deliberately to make written comments. And that’s exactly what peer reviewing is.

Third, reviewing can connect you with authors

Who can be grateful for your comments (if you sign your review), and with editors who will be grateful for your help. Building a network pays dividends, and an author or editor who remembers your thoughtful review may become a collaborator, a mentor, a source of advice, or just someone you can join for coffee and a chat at the next conference you attend. Yes, sadly, authors sometimes retaliate for an unfavourable review. At least early in your career, you might prefer to review anonymously – but you’re still building connections with editors. Those editors tend to be productive and influential scholars in your field. Don’t pass up chances to make connections like that.

Fourth, and for new authors perhaps most valuable, reviewing gives you a perspective on the publishing process

And that’s difficult to get any other way. You’ll see the draft manuscript to compare with the published version, of course; but in addition, you’ll (very often) see comments from the other reviewers, the decision letter from the editor, and the authors’ Response letter that accompanies the revision. As you steer your own manuscripts through the review process, you can learn from seeing how other authors handled criticism of their drafts. Did they disagree with your critique, but express that disagreement so rationally and professionally that you were persuaded? At some point, you’ll probably want to pull off that trick yourself. Did they betray their irritation and sabotage their revision’s chances? Perhaps you can notice a rhetorical flourish that’s best avoided. Chances to see the whole submission-review-and-revision process play out are hard to come by – and they’re instructive.

I don’t want to suggest that benefit to your own career is the only reason to get involved in peer review. Your own career will depend on others reviewing your work, which makes it appropriate to offer roughly the same amount of review service in return. (Many academics follow a rough rule of thumb, reviewing 2-4 papers for each one they submit.)  There’s also a more direct reason. Peer review has two functions: helping journals with decisions to accept or reject, yes; but also helping authors improve their manuscripts. We often focus on the gatekeeping function; but since most manuscripts are eventually published somewhere, the manuscript-improvement function is probably more important. I’ve felt a lot of satisfaction, over the years, that my reviews have helped authors publish better science – just as others have helped me publish better science through their reviews.

By the way, once you’ve reviewed a time or two, you’ll probably get more invitations than you can comfortably manage. It’s perfectly appropriate to turn some down; all of us do. You can review the manuscripts that are closest to your own work or those you find most interesting. Or, if you’re reluctant to provide a review service to a for-profit publisher, you can accept invitations from society-run and other non-profit journals. You won’t be short on opportunities.

So please, if you can, join the global team of reviewers we need for new results to become published knowledge. Maybe reviewing won’t strengthen your CV; but it can strengthen your scholarship.

More career development articles:

  • Top tips for academic mentoring
  • Research in Academic Careers
  • Balancing Academic Research and Teaching
  • Discussion as a Teaching Method

What did you think of our article? - please rate

5 / 5. 3


Share this article

Dr. Stephen Heard

Dr. Stephen Heard is an evolutionary ecologist and Professor of Biology at the University of New Brunswick in Canada. He is the author of The Scientist’s Guide to Writing and of Charles Darwin’s Barnacle and David Bowie’s Spider. He blogs about academia, science and many other things at Scientist Sees Squirrel, or you can find him on Twitter as @StephenBHeard.

Reader Interactions

You may also like:

  • Audience at the conference hall.

    Writing Abstracts for Conferences

  • Supporting Individual Researchers in a Publish-or-Perish Culture

    Supporting Individual Researchers in a Publish-or-Perish Culture

  • Quiet Mornings with a Tea

    How to stay calm for your PhD defence

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

18 − 8 =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Follow us

Searching for a job in the United Kingdom

Latest Jobs

  • Senior Scientific Associate, Pre-clinical Genome Editing Facility (12 months Fixed Term)

    Cancer Research UK Cambridge Institute, University of Cambridge

    Location: Cambridge

    Salary: £35,116 - £45,413 per annum


  • Senior Research Fellow

    College of Social Sciences - School of Social Policy and Society, University of Birmingham

    Location: Birmingham

    Salary: £57,422 - £66,537 Grade: 9


  • Housekeeping Assistant

    Trinity Hall , University of Cambridge

    Location: Cambridge

    Salary: £12.77 per hour, plus pension and benefits


  • Energy Manager

    CUEL, Coventry University Group (CUG)

    Location: Coventry

    Salary: £43,030 - £63,947


  • Clinical Innovation Fellow (2 posts available)

    College of Medical, Veterinary & Life Sciences - MVLS College Services, University of Glasgow

    Location: Glasgow

    Salary: £48,288 - £91,753 depending on experience


  • Research Fellow - GPS

    Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience (ICN), UCL

    Location: London

    Salary: £44,480 - £51,860


Footer

jobs.ac.uk - Great jobs for bright people
  • Find a Job
  • Find PhDs
  • Career Advice
  • Jobs by Email
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility Statement

Copyright © jobs.ac.uk 1998 - 2025

  • Find a Job
  • Find PhDs
  • Careers Advice
  • Jobs by Email
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility
jobs.ac.uk - Great jobs for bright people

Copyright © jobs.ac.uk 1998 - 2025