jobs.ac.uk - Great jobs for bright people
  • Find a Job
  • Find PhDs
  • Career Advice
  • Jobs by Email
  • Recruiters
  • Your Account

  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

career-advice.jobs.ac.uk

Secondary Sidebar

jobs.ac.uk Career Advice

  • CV and Cover Letter Advice
    • CV Tips
    • CV Templates
    • Cover Letters
    • Personal Profiles
    • CV Resources
  • Jobseeking and Interview Tips
    • Jobseeking Tips
    • Academic Interviews
    • Professional Interviews
    • Interview Questions tool
    • Jobseeking and Interview Resources
  • Career Development
    • Academic Careers
    • Research Careers
    • Professional Careers
    • Working in Industry
    • Career Development Resources
    • Global Careers
  • Studentship Advice
    • Masters
    • PhD
    • Studentship Resources
    • Vlogs
  • Resources
    • Ebooks and Toolkits
    • Careers Videos
    • Vlogs
    • Blog
    • Academic Case Studies
    • Professional Case Studies
    • Job Profiles
  • Country Profile
    • Africa
      • Egypt
      • Ghana
      • Kenya
      • Nigeria
      • South Africa
    • America
      • Canada
      • United States of America
    • Asia
      • Bahrain
      • Brunei
      • China
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Japan
      • Kazakhstan
      • Malaysia
      • Qatar
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • Turkey
      • United Arab Emirates
    • Europe
      • Belgium
      • Denmark
      • Finland
      • France
      • Germany
      • Ireland
      • Italy
      • Netherlands
      • Norway
      • Russia
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • United Kingdom
    • Oceania
      • Australia
      • New Zealand
  • Sections
    • CV and Cover Letter Advice
      • CV Tips
      • CV Templates
      • Cover Letters
      • Personal Profiles
      • CV Resources
    • Jobseeking and Interview Tips
      • Jobseeking Tips
      • Academic Interviews
      • Professional Interviews
      • Interview Questions tool
      • Jobseeking and Interview Resources
    • Career Development
      • Academic Careers
      • Research Careers
      • Professional Careers
      • Working in Industry
      • Career Development Resources
      • Global Careers
    • Studentship Advice
      • Masters
      • PhD
      • Studentship Resources
      • Vlogs
    • Resources
      • Ebooks and Toolkits
      • Careers Videos
      • Vlogs
      • Blog
      • Academic Case Studies
      • Professional Case Studies
      • Job Profiles
    • Country Profile
      • Africa
        • Egypt
        • Ghana
        • Kenya
        • Nigeria
        • South Africa
      • America
        • Canada
        • United States of America
      • Asia
        • Bahrain
        • Brunei
        • China
        • Hong Kong
        • India
        • Japan
        • Kazakhstan
        • Malaysia
        • Qatar
        • Saudi Arabia
        • Singapore
        • South Korea
        • Turkey
        • United Arab Emirates
      • Europe
        • Belgium
        • Denmark
        • Finland
        • France
        • Germany
        • Ireland
        • Italy
        • Netherlands
        • Norway
        • Russia
        • Spain
        • Sweden
        • Switzerland
        • United Kingdom
      • Oceania
        • Australia
        • New Zealand

The Positive Side of Rejection

rejection letter

…and How It Can Help You Achieve Better Things In Your Career.  Getting a rejection letter, whether it is your first, or 100th, never gets any easier.  There is a common human tendency to take it personally.  I know that when I get a rejection, it often eclipses a great success that I may have had literally a few days earlier.  It is often taken as a personal judgment on your work.  However, the reality is that there are many reasons, many of which are probably beyond your control, as to why your article, book, job application or funding application has been rejected.  Feedback can help you to turn your rejection into a stronger application in the future.  If there is literally nothing in the feedback that can help you, then it is more likely that the reviewer is not attempting to engage with your work.  In that case, it is best to put it down to a bad experience.  However, the worst thing to do would be to give up.  This article will look at how you can turn a rejection into something positive.

Find something meaningful in the reviews/feedback

If a review is written in a constructive and professional way, then there will be something positive in them.  Try to focus on these elements while putting the other, more difficult aspects into the background.  For most reviewers, they are engaging with your work in a deep way with the aim of helping you to improve it.  They may be harsher than your close friends or colleagues, but their intention is probably still the same.   In my experience, a review that has been critical of my work in a constructive way has, in the long term, helped me to pursue it further, and led to a much better publication in the long-term.  The prospect of greatly revising your work after investing your heart and soul into it is often not something that is particularly exciting, but if you remain focused on the goal of publication, and then you can get the job done.

Find something ridiculous in the reviews/feedback

If a review is particularly crushing, it is sometimes worth taking a step back and leaving it aside for a few days until you get the chance to calm down.  After this, you can revisit the review, hopefully in a less emotional state, and see what is in there.  Most reviews will have positive things that will help you, but there are examples of reviews that sadly, are ridiculous.  My research is on the Second World War, and I have had some very odd reviews of my work in the past.  For example, I have had reviewers lambast my work for not including what they termed as “a key publication on the war”  – a publication that turned out to be on the First World War, which is not the subject of my research!  Additionally, one reviewer even noted that if he/she was writing the article, it would be about something else.  This was particularly bizarre since it was me, and not them, who was authoring the piece!  When navigating through the reviews, it is worth remembering that reviewers give their time freely to do this, and most are well-intentioned.  However, being able to distinguish the ridiculous from the helpful can help you to cope with the rejection, and develop your strategy going forward.

Be persistent

Giving up at the first failure would not be good for your self-belief or your work.  Just because you have experienced this particular rejection does not mean that this will happen on the next attempt.  In many ways, success in the academic profession depends a lot on your persistence as well as your intelligence.  If the rejections seem t follow a specific pattern, it might be worth exploring this further with a view to see how you can change your strategy to maximise your chances of success.  Very few people experience success in everything that they try.  The key is to keep faith with what you do, not give up and explore several avenues with the aim of achieving your ultimate goal.  After all, JK Rowling has said that her first Harry Potter book was rejected by 12 different publishers before it was ultimately accepted.  Had she not been so persistent, she would not have experienced the huge success that she has done.  While this is not to say that academics could ever hope to aspire to the multi-million sales of Rowling, and the translations into several languages, the principle remains the same – persistence, and in the end, it should pay off.

The biggest difficulty is psychological

This is often the case, when you may think that you should not apply for a certain job “because you have no chance” or not submit an article for a journal because “my work is not good enough”.  We often find that we are our harshest critics.  We need to explore what has possibly made us feel this way.  Was it something that someone said to you?  Is it a bad review that you have had in the past?  Whatever the reason, the decision not to try could be the biggest barrier to your success.  While realising your weaknesses is important, realising your strengths is even more crucial in pursuing what you want to achieve.  Previous rejections do not define who you are – they form part of your story on a long road in academia.  Do not let it drag you down, use it as a motivation to improve and continue to strive for the best you can achieve with your life.

Finally….

Rejection is painful, but it is a process.  It never gets any easier, but the way you respond to it will help to shape your future going forward.  Remember that sometimes rejections are due to factors beyond your control.  But by pursuing your goals, taking on board the useful feedback you receive and setting yourself realistic goals will help you to have a clearer vision of your strategy going forward.


Share this article

Dr Mark Crowley

Dr Mark Crowley

Dr Mark J Crowley is an Associate Professor of History, and holds the distinguished Hubei Provincial ‘Chu Tian’ Research fellowship for the period 2014-2018 at the School of History, Wuhan University, China. He obtained his BScEcon Hons in Politics and Modern History at Cardiff University, an MSt in Modern History at Oxford University and his PhD from the University of London’s Institute of Historical Research, where he held an Arts and Humanities Research Council Collaborative Doctoral Award with the British Postal Museum and Archive. He has worked in China since March 2010 and at Wuhan University since March 2011. He is the co-editor of 2 volumes, Consuming Behaviours: Identity, Politics and Pleasure in Twentieth Century Britain (with Erika Rappaport and Sandra Dawson) published by Bloomsbury in 2015, and (with Sandra Dawson) Home Fronts: Britain and the Empire at War, 1939-45 (forthcoming with Boydell and Brewer, 2017). He is also the author of Post Office Women at War, 1939-45: Gender, Conflict and Public Service Employment (forthcoming with Bloomsbury Academic, 2017) as well as 10 journal articles on an eclectic range of topics concerning Britain in the Second World War, including women’s wartime experiences, gender inequality, public service employment, the British Home Front at war and trade unionism.

Reader Interactions

You may also like:

Being a Professor - A Personal Journey to Professorship
ECRs: Sharpening your virtual networking strategies
Getting your post-PhD job during COVID-19

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Follow us

Latest Jobs

  1. Research Fellow

    Division of Medicine, UCL

    Location(s): London

    Salary: £36,028 - £37,008 UCL Grade 7, per annum, inclusive of London Allowance


  2. Research Fellow

    Division of Medicine, UCL

    Location(s): London

    Salary: £36,028 - £37,008 UCL Grade 7, per annum, inclusive of London Allowance


  3. Senior Azure Platform Engineer

    Professional Services - IT, University of Leeds

    Location(s): Leeds

    Salary: £41,526 - £49,553 (Grade 8)


  4. Head of Health and Wellbeing

    Professional Services - Wellbeing, Safety & Health (including Occupational Health), University of Leeds

    Location(s): Leeds

    Salary: £51,034 - £59,134 per annum


  5. Senior Research Associate in Biostatistics/Epidemiology

    Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Bristol

    Location(s): Bristol

    Salary: £38,017 - £42,792 per annum


  6. Head of Integrated Research & Impact Support

    Corporate Services: Planning&Student Data, Bangor University

    Location(s): Bangor

    Salary: £51,034 - £59,135 p.a. Grade 9


Footer

jobs.ac.uk - Great jobs for bright people
  • Find a Job
  • Find PhDs
  • Career Advice
  • Jobs by Email
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility Statement

Copyright © jobs.ac.uk 1998 - 2019

  • Find a Job
  • Find PhDs
  • Careers Advice
  • Jobs by Email
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility
jobs.ac.uk - Great jobs for bright people

Copyright © jobs.ac.uk 1998 - 2019