The PhD Ethics Process

Ethics Process

This article explains the importance, steps, and principles of the ethics process in research. It explores what ethical approval is and why it matters. It also highlights offers practical advice on how to pass the ethics review successfully.

Understanding the PhD Ethics Process

Ethical review is one of the first formal steps in any research project, ensuring your research is conducted responsibly and with integrity. Whether your study involves human participants, animal subjects, or fieldwork, you must demonstrate that risks have been assessed and managed. The ethics process is designed to protect not just participants and animals, but also the researcher, the research institution, and the wider environment. It encourages you to think critically about the impact of your work and how to maintain high ethical standards from project design through to publication.

Ethics guidance is shaped by institutional policies and national/international frameworks, which vary by discipline. For example:

• Psychology (BPS Code of Human Research Ethics)
• Medical Research (NHS Research Ethics)
• Animal Welfare (AWERB)

Why Ethical Approval Matters

Ethical approval ensures that research is guided by principles of fairness, respect, and responsibility. It requires researchers to demonstrate that:

• Participants and animals are treated with care and respect.
• Risks to welfare, privacy, and the environment are minimised.
• Research is conducted safely and transparently.
• Data are collected, stored, and shared responsibly.

Approval from your university’s Research Ethics Committee confirms that your study meets professional, legal, and institutional standards. In many fields, particularly those involving human participants or animals, ethical approval is a legal requirement before data collection can begin.

The Ethics Process: Key Stages

Although details vary by university and discipline, most researchers follow a similar process:

1. Identify potential ethical issues
   During your proposal stage, consider whether your project involves people, animals, fieldwork, or potentially hazardous materials.
2. Prepare your application
   Complete your institution’s ethics form, providing a clear description of your methodology, consent or welfare procedures, data management plan, and risk assessment.
3. Review and feedback
   A Research Ethics Committee will review your application. They may request amendments or clarifications before granting approval.
4. Approval and compliance
   Once approved, you must follow the approved procedures precisely. Any change to your study design will require further ethical review and approval.
5. Ongoing ethical responsibility
   Receiving ethical approval isn’t always the end of the process. Researchers have a continuing duty to uphold ethical principles throughout the entire project. This includes conducting fieldwork or data collection safely and respectfully, managing and storing data securely, protecting participant or species welfare, and ensuring that the analysis, interpretation, and publication of findings remain honest, transparent, and responsible.

Working with Human Participants

If your research involves human participants, your methods may include interviews, surveys, focus groups, or behavioural experiments. These approaches require careful planning to ensure informed consent, privacy, and the wellbeing of everyone involved. Key ethical considerations include:

• Informed consent: Participants must voluntarily agree to take part, with a clear understanding of what the study involves.
• Confidentiality and data protection: Personal data should be securely stored and anonymised.
• Minimising harm: Avoid psychological stress, discomfort, or reputational risk to participants.
• Vulnerable groups: Take additional precautions when working with children, patients, or other vulnerable individuals.

Working with Animals: The 3Rs and Welfare

For research involving animals, ethical review ensures that welfare standards are upheld and that the research complies with national legislation.

The foundation of animal research ethics is the 3Rs Principle:

• Replacement: Use alternatives to animals wherever possible, such as computer models or cell cultures.
• Reduction: Minimise the number of animals used while maintaining robust scientific outcomes.
• Refinement: Improve housing, handling, and experimental methods to reduce suffering and stress.

Fieldwork and Environmental Ethics

Field-based research raises additional ethical and safety considerations, particularly in ecological, geographical, and anthropological studies. Animal welfare considerations also apply to fieldwork. Researchers must consider capture stress, tagging impacts, and disturbance to wild populations.

• Environmental impact: Minimise disturbance to habitats and species.
• Cultural sensitivity: Obtain permissions from local authorities and communities.
• Personal safety: Conduct thorough risk assessments for working in hazardous environments.

Many institutions require separate fieldwork risk assessments alongside ethics approval.

Practical Tips for Navigating the Process

• Start early: Ethical review can take several weeks or months as Ethics boards only meet semi-regularly
• Conducting a pilot study before your main research can help identify practical and ethical challenges early.

• Be specific: Vague or incomplete applications often lead to delays.
• Use guidance: Consult your supervisor, ethics officer, and refer to Ethical guidelines.
• Keep records: Retain all correspondence and approval documents for publication.

Conclusion

The PhD ethics process is more than a procedural requirement; it is a foundation for responsible, high-quality research. Whether you are interviewing participants, working with animals, or conducting fieldwork, strong ethical awareness ensures that your research benefits others without causing harm. Approaching the process thoughtfully and proactively not only helps you secure approval but also strengthens the scientific and moral integrity of your work.

Share this article